The
Graveyard Book by Neil Gaiman and the Jungle Book by Rudyard Kipling have many
striking similarities throughout their stories. They both revolve around a
young boy who has been taken away from human civilization and is raised based
on the Laws of the land. Particularly in the beginning of each of these stories,
the similarities are rather apparent.
In the Jungle Book, the wolves find Mowgli after
Shere Khan attempted to kill him. When the wolves save the man club, Shere Khan
demands for the man cub to be returned to him, as it is his kill. The wolves
refuse, and ultimately decide to keep him as their own when Mother Wolf
confronts Shere Khan by saying, “The man’s cub is mine, Lungri – mine to me! He
shall not be killed. He shall live to run with the Pack,” (Kipling 9). This interaction
is parallel to Mrs. Owens demanding that Bod be kept in the Graveyard to
protect him from the man Jack. She shows her determination similar to Mother Wolf
when she rebuttals, “’I can look after him […] as well as his own mama. She already
gave him to me. Look: I’m holding him, aren’t I? I’m touching him,’” (Gaiman
22). Here, it is clear that the mothers are the influential force in each of
these stories for persuading the others to allow the boys to stay. They are
protecting the children from the ones trying to kill them, and this is
consistent in both stories.
However, the mother’s will is not enough
to persuade everyone; there is a set of laws that must be followed in both
cases. Mowgli must be brought to Akela, the Lone Wolf, in order to decide his
fate. Akela is described as “the great gray Lone Wolf, who led all the Pack,”
(Kipling 11). Bod, too, must be brought to the leader of the graveyard, who is
described by Gaiman as, “a woman, clothed head to foot in gray” (Gaiman 30). In
both stories, the leader of the “pack” is a lone individual clad in gray.
There is similarity between
Bagheera and Silas in these two stories; neither were born into the Jungle or
Graveyard. Bagheera tells Mowgli, “I was born among men […] I had never seen
the jungle,” (Kipling 16). Mrs. Owens reveals that Silas had been given Freedom
of the Graveyard when she says, “It en’t the first time we’d’ve given the
Freedom of the Graveyard to an outsider” (Gaiman 23). And, as a result, both Bagheera
and Silas act as vouches for the young boys to be allowed to stay among the
others. They sympathize with the boys, as they too had to be accepted by their
peers. Bagheera and Silas end up as teachers for the strange boys, as they feel
the most empathy towards them.
The Graveyard Book and The Jungle Book
have almost mirror image introductions. The similarities can be seen in the
threat of the boys’ lives, the mothers’ protective and persuasive nature, the portrayal
of the leaders, and the boys’ teachers.
No comments:
Post a Comment