The Course Blog for Honors H 234, Twice Told Tales. Spring 2014. Indiana University at Bloomington.
Sunday, March 2, 2014
Oscar de Leon, a superhero's ending.
The final moments of Oscar’s life as revealed in
“The Final Letter” of The Brief Wondrous
Life of Oscar Wao did not seem to agree with the rest of Oscar’s time on
this planet. In this chapter, Yunior reveals that Oscar did manage to get away
with Ybón and lose his virginity to her towards the end of his twenty-seven
days in the Dominican Republic. This revelation seemed to me like a way to
provide a happy ending to the story, and didn’t actually agree with the rest of
Oscar’s misfortunes. Throughout the entire book, Oscar desperately struggles
for any girl to give him the time of day; and although a few are nice to him,
Oscar’s passionate, borderline-obsessive love is never reciprocated. Until is
he meets Ybón. She initiates a conversation with Oscar and Oscar falls
irrevocably in love with her for the rest of his life, even to the point of returning
to the Dominican Republic after his great beat down, a trip which he probably
knows will cost him his life. I thought that Oscar’s pestering of Ybón despite
her protests was very in character – he never gives up fighting for a chance on
love. However, as Oscar was unlucky in every aspect of his life, especially
with women, it doesn’t seem in line with the rest of the story that right
before he dies he ‘gets the girl’. This doesn’t seem fair to the Oscar’s
characterization and all of his misfortunes. It seems like a way to add a happy
or redemptive ending to a story that didn’t need one. This small detail, which
was the greatest victory to Oscar, just did not seem to fit. I questioned
whether Oscar may have been making this up or at least greatly inflating what
actually occurred. But I do not think that Oscar was lying. He never bowed to
the pressure of Dominican masculinity, lying about his sexual escapades or his
luck (or lack thereof) with women. So I don’t think he would have lied about Ybón
to Yunior just to give everyone something to remember him by; that would not
have been Oscar. I also thought that perhaps this revelation was included to
give Oscar the superhero’s ending that he had read and written about so many
times. Although I was happy that Oscar was able to get the one thing he wanted
most in life, finally ‘getting the girl’ in his last days is not in line with
the rest of Oscar’s character. Oscar wasn’t a superhero, despite all of his
hopes and dreams to be. He was just Oscar, which, in the end, was enough.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment